The January 2010 death of JoAnn Matouk Romain gets even more mysterious when her family learns of two other cases connected to hers. One, which seems to not even be real, and another that is all too real and shares some eerie similarities.
Oct 12
MISSING: Gregory ‘Keith’ Mann Jr.
It’s the kind of detail that lingers: a meeting, just after midnight… that no one can explain. In May 1997, 20-year-old Keith Mann was building a future—new apartment, new job, new fiancée. But sometime after being dropped off at home late that night, Keith stepped back out into ... Show More
31m 15s
Jul 2025
277. The Family Feud Murder
GARRETTS CUP COLLECTING APP: http://thecupboardapp.com/mwmh When a devoted mother is found dead in her Illinois home, a quiet community is left searching for answers. As investigators dig deeper, unsettling details begin to surface. In this episode, Payton and Garrett investigate ... Show More
48m 57s
Jan 2024
Phoebe’s Fall: The Brief Life and Mysterious Demise of Phoebe Handsjuk
In the heart of the city, the Phoebe Handsjuk case stands as a puzzling mystery, where a woman's inexplicable death raises more questions than answers, shrouding the investigation in suspense.
DISCLAIMER: This episode contains explicit content. Parental guidance is advised fo ... Show More
50m 58s