logo
episode-header-image
Apr 2021
18m 56s

12 of 20: Guilty Face

AUDIOCHUCK
About this episode
Jeff’s current defense attorney, Frances Watson, invites Delia to her “Pelley Case” war room at IU McKinney School of Law and lays out the facts she is using to contest Jeff’s conviction. Delia uncovers that former Saint Joseph County Police detectives now contradict some of their original theories. 
Up next
Apr 2021
13 of 20: Check The Bank
<p>Delia revisits the history of an enormous financial scandal with Bob Pelley’s former employer, Landmark Bank. The CounterClock investigation reveals never-before heard testimony from a woman who told authorities that Bob was afraid of people from his past in Florida.</p><p> </ ... Show More
26m 29s
Apr 2021
14 of 20: Fines & Grace
<p>The CounterClock investigation pivots to focus on the disappearance of a man in Southwest Florida seven months before the Pelley murders. Eric Dawson’s story is integrally important for the remainder of the series. </p><p> </p><p>For even more time with CounterClock, follow us ... Show More
18m 6s
Apr 2021
15 of 20: Hogs & Snakes
<p>Delia investigates the brutal murder of Eric Dawson in Fort Myers, Florida. A former lead detective on the case explains the complicated secrets of the slain land developer’s life and business. Family friends of the Pelleys’ emerge as persons of interest in Eric’s case.</p><p> ... Show More
23m 50s
Recommended Episodes
Jan 2023
Cold Confession (Susan Morris)
<p>A San Antonio detective sifts through misleading witnesses, dubious admissions and overlooked evidence to rectify a disturbing, decade-old investigation. </p><p> </p><p>For episode information and photos, please visit <a href="https://anatomyofmurder.com/"><strong>https://anat ... Show More
45m 13s
Jun 2024
The Delphi Murders: The Defense's "Ding Dong" Document
<p>The defense made a filing in the Delphi case outlining why they feel Judge Frances Gull is wrong to not recuse herself. They also complain that she makes unhappy faces at them, and that she doesn't affectionately refer to them as "ding dongs." </p><p>Support The Murder Sheet b ... Show More
50m 42s
Dec 2022
Two Children - Part 2 (Justin & Delmar Delgado)
<p>Sights are set on a prime suspect, but police have only one shot to get a confession. A criminal profiler helps investigators get justice for the Delgado boys.</p><p>For episode information and photos, please visit <a href="https://anatomyofmurder.com/"><strong>https://anatomy ... Show More
46m 47s
Nov 2021
Ep 8 of 10: Holes in the Case (Part 2)
<p>It’s courtroom 101: the prosecution’s trying to make a case, the defense is trying to get their client off, and it’s the jury’s job to figure out the truth. But how much of the science that’s presented at court is actually scientific? Ben and Sharon look closely at specific pi ... Show More
35 m
Nov 2023
Interrogation Room
After a 17-hour-long interrogation, a woman confesses to a murder. But then, evidence surfaces proving that she can’t have actually done it – and that it was a false confession. Today, we’re looking at what goes on in an interrogation room – and hear a recording from inside. Maur ... Show More
55m 25s
May 2025
Chapter 14 | A Town on Trial
<p>Unpacking the trial of Delbert Tallman and making the case that Tallman is NOT Heidi Martin’s likely killer.</p><p>Special thank you to the following Dark Valley listeners for their dedicated support of the show: M Charles, Tara F, Debie Burton, Sandi C. W., Parker D. and Bria ... Show More
1 h
Listen to millions of songs and podcasts on Anghami