logo
episode-header-image
Dec 2021
52m 32s

1848 and All That

DAVID RUNCIMAN AND CATHERINE CARR
About this episode

David and Helen talk to historian Chris Clark about the 1848 revolutions and what they teach us about political change. What explains the contagiousness of the revolutionary moment? Is it possible to combine parliamentary reform with street politics? Where does counter-revolution get its power?


The revolutions of 1848 started with a small civil war in Switzerland in 1847.

  • In 1848, there was a cascade of simultaneous uprisings across the continent. There were the spring revolutions; then in the summer, the liberal and conservative wings began to fight each other.
  • In the autumn, counter revolutions began in earnest. But the left revived itself, launching revolution 2.0. Finally, in the summer of 1849, the counter revolution largely prevailed.


These were revolutions about political and social order, but also about national order.

  • The Hungarians, for example, declared independence from Vienna and fought not just against the Austrians but against a range of other nationalities.


What accounts for the simultaneity of these revolutions?

  • A continent-wide socio-economic crisis began with an agrarian crisis in 1845. Food became much more expensive at a time when people spent most of their money on food.
  • The agrarian crisis then triggered a downturn in trade and consumption. 


Why wasn’t there a revolution in Britain? 

  • One reason is that the country was so efficiently policed.
  • Another is that Britain was able to export potentially problematic people to the colonies. 
  • The imperial economy also allowed them to outsource price-shock problems.


The forces of counterrevolution were primarily those of monarchism and money.

  • Europe already had an order, the order of 1815; monarchs wanted to restore it.
  • Revolutions are spontaneous, but counterrevolutionaries can bide their time strategically.
  • The liberal great powers didn’t support the revolutions, but the conservative ones supported the counter revolutions.
  • You can also read this as the death throes of the counterrevolutionary order. They won’t make common cause again. 


The revolutions of 1848 combined radical street politics with legislative politics. The institutional side of the revolution seemed to win.

  • Constitutions proliferated after 1848. 
  • The tense relationship between the street and representative processes is at the core of what these revolutions were about.  




Up next
May 2023
New Podcast: These Times
UnHerd political editor Tom McTague and Cambridge professor Helen Thompson team up to investigate the history of today’s politics — and what it means for our future. Each week they will explore the great forces, ideas and events that led us to where we are, whether in Britain, th ... Show More
52s
Apr 2023
New Podcast: Where Are You Going?
Talking Politics producer Catherine Carr returns to her role as mic-wielder in 'Where Are You Going?' a unique storytelling podcast, delivered in bite-size episodes. Called 'utterly compelling and unique' by the Financial Times, 'engrossing' by The Times and 'riveting' by The Spe ... Show More
3m 39s
Apr 2023
New Podcast: Past Present Future
Past Present Future is a new weekly podcast with David Runciman, host of Talking Politics, exploring the history of ideas from politics to philosophy, culture to technology. David talks to historians, novelists, scientists and many others about where the most interesting ideas co ... Show More
2m 18s
Recommended Episodes
Jan 2012
1848: Year of Revolution
Melvyn Bragg and his guests discuss 1848, the year that saw Europe engulfed in revolution. Across the continent, from Paris to Palermo, liberals rose against conservative governments. The first stirrings of rebellion came in January, in Sicily; in February the French monarchy fel ... Show More
41m 57s
Feb 2019
Oliver Cromwell and the English Revolution
In this video from the 2018 Revolution Festival, Alan Woods (editor of In Defence of Marxism) discusses the events of the English Civil War - England's revolution. The civil war in the 17th century saw the forces of Parliament battling against the monarchy of Charles I, fighting ... Show More
1h 7m
May 2018
E43 La 2ème révolution française
Quoi ? Une 2ème révolution française ?! On connaît celle de 1789 mais la 2ème, c’était quand ? C’était en mai 1968. D’accord, le mot « révolution » est peut-être un peu exagéré... Il n’y a pas eu de révolution politique. Par contre, on a assisté à une révolution des mœurs et de l ... Show More
34m 10s
Jul 2020
French Revolution, the Reign of Terror, and Rewriting History (Part 3) [E157]
French Revolution began 150 years of chaos, war, bloodshed, revolution…. Each movement being eaten by the next…France in the 1789 had LOTS of problems: high tax on poor, Rich, oppression etc.  CLEARLY in need of Revolution. America had just gone through their own revolution. But ... Show More
32m 48s
Nov 2023
1917: The October Revolution
We are republishing Alan Wood's series on the Russian Revolution as a podcast, originally released to mark the centenary of the greatest event in human history. In the final episode of the 1917 series, Alan Woods discusses the October Revolution, when the workers and peasants of ... Show More
24m 39s
May 2023
326: The Year of Revolutions: 1848
Few years in European History saw as much change and turmoil as 1848: across the continent, from Vienna to Paris to Palermo, mass protests took place, catching the old elites by surprise. The political order that stood strong since the defeat of Napoleon fell aside, making way fo ... Show More
1h 2m
Dec 2023
311. La révolution des œillets au Portugal, avec Victor Pereira
L’invité : Victor Pereira, MCF à l’université de Pau et des pays de l’Adour Le livre : C’est le peuple qui commande. La Révolution des Œillets : 1974-1976, Paris, éditions du Détour, 2023. La discussion : Introduction (1:00) Une révolution souvent euphémisée ou effacée À quelle d ... Show More
1h 6m
Feb 2024
The Great French Revolution
The Great French Revolution was one of the greatest events in human history. In just four years, the masses rose up and swept away the ancient regime that had stood for centuries, igniting revolutionary flames across Europe. Yet these heroic efforts ultimately prepared the way fo ... Show More
46m 50s