logo
episode-header-image
Oct 2021
15m 9s

Second Date Update: It's a Costume Dummy

iHeartPodcasts

About this episode

One of our listeners met his date at a Halloween party when he over-confidently used a pick-up line... That seriously backfired. He quickly realized his mistake and wants our help redeeming himself! 

Up next

Today
FULL SHOW: Jeff’s Tech Crash Out Parody, Traumatic Turkey Memories + Surprise Mom Date (11/20/26)
Every Sunday, we host one of our FULL HOUR episodes from our main show feed, Brooke & Jeffrey! We'd love to hear your feedback...but please send all negative reviews to Jeffrey. FULL SHOW: Friday, November 20th, 2026 Get your 2nd Date Update Merch For A Cause HERE! Curious if we ... 
1h 6m
Yesterday
Second Date Update Classics: Early Bird Sees The Worm + Miss Krustworthy Returns
Part 1 One of our listeners definitely crossed the line in OVERSHARING, and while it wasn’t on purpose it did cause the most embarrassing 5 seconds of his life. Part 2 Julia met a guy on a trip to the Caribbean, and now she needs our help tracking him down for an INTERNATIONAL SE ... 
37m 40s

Recommended Episodes

Nov 2025
Second Date Update Classics: It's A Costume Dummy + Blackout Drunk Shuttlecock
Part 1 The guy in today’s Second Date Update tried a pickup line that was cringey, not just on one level… but on MULTIPLE LEVELS and he quickly realized he needed our help. Part 2 One of our listeners found themselves in the middle of an epic house party and he thinks he found a ... 
36m 52s
Jul 2024
Second Date Update: Jesus Take The Selfie
One of our listeners was convinced into doing a selfless, good deed on his first date, and somehow it completely backfired...See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information. 
18m 38s
Oct 2024
Second Date Update: Halloween Ghostface Ditcher
No party is better for random makeouts than a Halloween Party! One of our listeners was close to getting lucky but fate (or something else) intervened and now she needs a Second Date Update!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information. 
16m 20s
Oct 2025
Second Date Update Classics: 10 Pin Mixup + Pop Goes the Relationship
Part 1How badly are you willing to embarrass yourself if it means getting a date with that special person? One of our listeners went to the limit LIVE ON AIR and you get to hear it!Part 2A listener on the phone today says his first kiss with his date left a LOT to be desired… and ... 
36m 4s
Feb 2025
Second Date Update: V-Day Pass Out
One of our listeners ended up in the HOSPITAL right in the middle of his first date… and he can’t believe he was naïve enough to make this dumb, avoidable choice… You’ll hear it in a special Valentine’s Day Second Date Update!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information. 
16m 24s
Oct 2024
Second Date Update Classic: Age-Ja-Vu
What’s the opposite of a Wingman? Whatever you call it, that type of guy is what ruined our listeners date.  Now he wants our help to try and save it with a Second Date!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information. 
16m 9s
Nov 2024
Second Date Update Classic: Halloween Role Reversal
The guy on the phone today wants to try and recreate his perfect first date all over again… exactly one year to the day. It involves wearing children’s costumes and it’s happening in a Second Date Update!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information. 
15m 12s
Feb 2025
Second Date Update: Red Flaggy Much?
One of our listeners said he made a restaurant faux pas RIGHT AWAY on his date before he even put down the menu. We’ll talk to him and see if it derailed his chances in your Second Date Update!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information. 
17m 15s
Feb 2020
2nd Date Meredith and Mike (Ur Smurfin' Crazy) Part 2
Ur Smurfin’ Crazy - One of our listeners feels horrible about the mistake she made during her date and the guy even called her out on it… We’re sift through her embarrassment and try to salvage a second date! 
9m 13s
Dec 2024
Second Date Update: Happy Shamaversary
One of our listeners tried to go the “funny” route for a first date activity and it ended up stinking worse than Brooke’s microwaved lunches. You’ll hear what happened in a Second Date Update!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information. 
17m 48s