logo
episode-header-image
Oct 2021
1h 20m

US Liberalism & Islamic Exceptionalism w...

MUHAMMAD JALAL
About this episode

As you all know, this podcast is no stranger to dissecting the narrative forwarded by liberals in general and those within our community that self-identify as Muslim liberals. And if you know me you would know that I don’t particularly find the modernist narrative appealing nor elegant in their appeals to what I and I think most Muslims see as the ideas of an incoherent worldview that has undermined human societies the world over.

With these caveats in mind, this episode we dedicate to a discussion with an American Muslim liberal, Dr Shadi Hamid. I have followed his work for some years and although we part company on a number of issues, as you will hear, I do feel Shadi is a reluctant liberal, open to criticise not only those inconsistencies he witnesses but also he attempts to make sense of American foreign policy in light of his values and I am not sure he is always successful in reaching a satisfactory answer.

We discuss American liberalism, the trends towards nativism, exemplified in the near re-election of Donald Trump last year but also how he reconciles his liberal worldview with his Islamic faith, which I know he thinks a lot about. 

Shadi has written a number of books on the Muslim world, this is where he made his name in American political and academic circles, so we spend time talking about the attitudes of Muslims in the Muslim world towards Islam as well as the often-simplistic way US policy treats the Middle East and Islamic parties.

For more links to Shadi Hamid's biography and works, please view the Insights page on the show 

Follow us on Twitter here: https://twitter.com/jalalayn and https://twitter.com/thinking_muslim

Website: thinkingmuslim.com



Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Up next
Yesterday
We’ve Waited Long Enough— The Ummah Must Unite with Dr. Wajid Akhter Ep. 3
Donate to our charity partner Baitulmaal here: http://btml.us/thinkingmuslim Help us expand our Muslim media project here: https://www.thinkingmuslim.com/membershipDr. Wajid Akhter joins The Thinking Youth podcast for one of our most urgent conversations yet; on why unity feels s ... Show More
1h 11m
Jul 7
I Was Inside the U.S. State Department - Until Gaza Broke Me with Josh Paul.
Help us expand our Muslim media project here: https://www.thinkingmuslim.com/membershipDonate to our charity partner Baitulmaal here: http://btml.us/thinkingmuslim Josh Paul served as a director within the US State Department under Biden. He was the first to resign in protest aga ... Show More
52m 24s
Jul 4
Has Sufism Become a Tool for Autocrats? with Dr Shadee El-Masry
Help us expand our Muslim media project here: https://www.thinkingmuslim.com/membershipDonate to our charity partner Baitulmaal here: http://btml.us/thinkingmuslim Modern day autocrats turn to Sufi movements to justify their tyranny. With an emphasis on the personal and the spiri ... Show More
54m 39s
Recommended Episodes
Jul 2016
Shadi Hamid on "Islamic Exceptionalism"
Shadi Hamid is a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution’s Project on US Relations with the Islamic World and the author of the new book Islamic Exceptionalism: How the Struggle Over Islam Is Reshaping the World. Shadi sat down with Benjamin Wittes to discuss his book, which e ... Show More
57m 1s
Feb 2017
Islam Is Neither An Identity Movement Nor A Race: It's A Faith, A Diverse Idea - 2/4/17
Dr. Jasser revisits the hysteria behind the executive order on immigration from Terror hotspots. He confronts the exploitation of Muslims for the self-serving identity politics of the left. Join Zuhdi as he exposes the hypocrisy behind the left's cooperation with the far-right Is ... Show More
54m 27s
Dec 2016
#55 — Islamism vs Secularism
Sam Harris speaks with Shadi Hamid about the power of religious belief, the failure of the Left, Islamist democracy, free speech, profiling, white nationalism, Obama’s foreign policy and other topics. If the Making Sense podcast logo in your player is BLACK, you can SUBSCRIBE to ... Show More
1h 14m
Sep 2019
EP 160: Endgame: The CVE and the UAE Scheme | Raja Abdulhaq and Ahmed Shaikh
Resources related to the discussion: Ahmed Shaikh article on MuslimMatters: https://muslimmatters.org/2019/08/29/sherman-jackson-cve-uae-and-some-questions/ Ali Al-Arian article: https://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/opinion/political-impotence-muslim-american-community-1908201518399 ... Show More
1h 52m
Jun 2017
#81 — Leaving Islam
Sam Harris speaks with Sarah Haider about her organization Ex-Muslims of North America, how the political Left is confused about Islam, "rape culture" under Islam, honesty without bigotry, stealth theocracy, immigration, the prospects of reforming Islam, and other topics. If the ... Show More
49m 47s
Jun 2023
Ep 161 | The Islamist Head-fake: Support Democracy, Reject Liberty
In this week’s episode join Dr. Jasser as he looks at the crux of the debate raging across Muslim-majority communities about whether the goal for modern society is democracy or liberty. As an American patriot, Zuhdi reminds us that there’s a reason the word democracy doesn’t appe ... Show More
40m 46s
Dec 2023
David M. Freidenreich, "Jewish Muslims: How Christians Imagined Islam as the Enemy" (U California Press, 2023)
Uncovering the hidden history of Islamophobia and its surprising connections to the long-standing hatred of Jews.Hatred of Jews and hatred of Muslims have been intertwined in Christian thought since the rise of Islam. In Jewish Muslims: How Christians Imagined Islam as the Enemy  ... Show More
57m 6s
Apr 2024
Sharia Law, the State & Modernity’s Moral Predicament | Wael Hallaq
Renowned professor of ethics, law and political thought and leading scholar of Islamic Legal Studies, Dr Wael Hallaq, joins us on this episode of the afikra podcast to discuss Sharia law, the modern state, Legal Orientalism, and the idea of a "stateless" yet still orderly world.D ... Show More
1h 13m
Apr 2024
SHIA Islam vs. RED PILL MOVEMENT! (Ft. Hassan Al-Qadri)
Millions of Muslims are accessing toxic content online, sometimes stumbling upon discussions about women and masculinity. The Red Pill vs woke liberal movement is gaining massive traction, attracting streamers and influencers who convert to Islam and are indoctrinated to believe ... Show More
1h 20m