What Happened to Amy?

About this episode

For more than 30 years, Ohio investigators have searched for answers in the murder of 10-year-old Amy Mihaljevic. Now they’re enlisting your help to solve the case. Josh Mankiewicz reports.

Examine the evidence in this case: https://www.nbcnews.com/dateline/in-the-news/watch-dateline-episode-what-happened-amy-now-n1279797

If you have any tips for investigators in Amy’s case, call Bay Village PD at (440) 871-1234

Up next

Yesterday

4 - The Reckoning

Days before Robert Roberson's scheduled execution, his lawyer scrambles to save his life. The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals weighs in. Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

23m 12s

Yesterday

3 - A Date to Die

As Robert Roberson’s execution nears, his attorney uncovers critical evidence and unlikely new allies, including Texas lawmakers and the detective who helped put Robert on death row. Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collectio ... Show More

29m 57s

Yesterday

2 - “I’m Astonished”

Attorney Gretchen Sween takes on Robert's case and pieces together Nikki’s overlooked medical history. She tracks down a witness from his trial who has new information. Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of p ... Show More

25m 39s

Recommended Episodes

Oct 2019

Who Killed Amy Mihaljevic? 30 YEARS- PART 1 of 6

This week’s sponsor is BetterHelp.com Save 10% with my promo code WHOwww.betterhelp.com/WhoFollow me on Twitter @billhuffman3If you'd like to help support the podcast via PayPal with my email billhuffman123@yahoo.com or Venmo @Billhuffman3http://www.cityofbayvillage.com/safety-se ... Show More

35m 54s

Aug 2019

Amy Sher

On Monday, October 14, 2002, Amy Sher left her job at the Lahey Clinic earlier than usual. On Tuesday and Wednesday she called in sick to work. And then on Thursday, October 17, her husband Robert Desmond called in sick for her and told Amy’s employer that she would not be return ... Show More

1h 3m

May 2023

Unsolved Homicide: Beverly Jaye Potter-Mintz

When a young coastal North Carolina mother is brutally murdered in her own home, investigators determine that her killer was likely a man who had responded to a classified sale ad she’d placed in a local paper. Investigators continue to pursue a killer who’s managed to evade law ... Show More

40m 32s

Nov 2023

Arlis Perry // 356

In October of 1974, a 19-year-old woman headed to her church at midnight after she and her husband got into an argument. But when she didn’t return home that night, her husband reported her missing. When her body was found inside in a ritualistic manner just hours later, police b ... Show More

45m 27s

Jul 2022

Oakey "Al" Kite // 219

In 2004, a well-liked man went missing from Aurora, Colorado after dropping his girlfriend off at the airport. When police conducted a wellness check at his home 2 days later, they found him brutally and methodically murdered in his own basement, with no apparent motive and no su ... Show More

37m 24s

Dec 2022

Unsolved Quadruple Homicide: The Dardeen Family

When an Illinois couple and their young children are murdered in an act of profound violence, investigators struggle to find anyone who might’ve wanted to harm the well-liked family. A decades-long investigation explores multiple possibilities, including the involvement of serial ... Show More

45m 25s

Feb 2022

Justice for Lacey | 9

On a cold, snowy evening in the fall of 2012, a series of 911 calls led Calgary police to multiple scenes. At one of those locations, investigators made a disturbing discovery — the body of Lacey Jones-McKnight. As homicide investigators took over the case, they learned the kille ... Show More

47m 33s

Apr 2023

Unsolved Disappearance: Ilene Misheloff

When a girl vanishes from California’s Bay Area while walking home from school, it quickly becomes apparent that she was likely abducted. Investigators explore a series of potential suspects, each stranger than the last, in this episode of Last Seen Alive. If you know anything ... Show More

48m 35s

Listen to millions of songs and podcasts on Anghami