logo
episode-header-image
Sep 2021
1h 11m

S6 Ep12: The Murder of Baby Elsie

Seeing Red
About this episode
In 2016, 340 children were adopted in Wales. Ten month old Shayla O’Brien was one of those 340 children.

Like most children put up for adoption, Shayla had entered this world under difficult circumstances. Born to a drug-addicted mother, she was added to the child protection register at birth, in November 2014. She left hospital when she was five days old and she was quickly taken into care by the Vale of Glamorgan council, before being placed with a foster family, where she remained until she was placed with an adoptive family in September 2015, at the age of ten months.

This adoptive family consisted of two parents, Craig and Matthew Scully-Hicks, and a previously adopted older child. Matthew assumed the majority of the caring responsibilities for Shayla, and she remained as a 'looked after child' following her placement with the family until the making of the Adoption Order. The Adoption Order was granted in May 2016 and Shayla’s name was changed to Elsie. She was now officially a member of the Scully-Hicks family.

This should have been the beginning of a happier life for Elsie, a life filled with love and opportunity…

But it wasn’t to be. Just two weeks after the official adoption had been granted, Elsie would lie dead in her bed at the University of Wales Hospital, having suffered a catalogue of catastrophic injuries at the hands of Matthew Scully-Hicks. Just what happened to baby Elise...

Join us as we take a deep dive into this disturbing and tragic case.

Patreon:
www.patreon.com/seeingredpodcast

Sponsor:
www.issuu.com/podcast - use promo code red

Theme Music:
Composed by Holly-Jane Shears - www.soundcloud.com/DeadDogInBlackBag

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Up next
Jul 8
She Was Only 12: The Murder of Nikki Conroy
It was an ordinary school day—until it wasn’t. Twelve-year-old Nikki Conroy should have been safe within the walls of her classroom. Instead, a stranger walked in, armed with a knife and intent on violence. What followed was a terrifying attack that left one child dead, several o ... Show More
54m 57s
Jul 2
William & Zachary Zulock: Predators In Plain Sight
In this harrowing episode we uncover the deeply disturbing case of William and Zachary Zulock — a seemingly picture-perfect couple from Georgia who adopted two young boys, only to exploit and abuse them in the most vile ways imaginable. Behind their carefully curated social media ... Show More
45m 59s
Jul 1
William & Zachary Zulock: Predators In Plain Sight
In this harrowing episode we uncover the deeply disturbing case of William and Zachary Zulock — a seemingly picture-perfect couple from Georgia who adopted two young boys, only to exploit and abuse them in the most vile ways imaginable. Behind their carefully curated social media ... Show More
42m 8s
Recommended Episodes
Jul 2023
Episode 305 - Natalia Grace: The Orphan
In 2009, the horror film ‘Orphan’ told the tale of a couple who unwittingly adopted a 9-year-old girl, who (spoilers) turned out to be a murderous, adult woman.Sometimes though, reality is stranger than fiction. A year after the film’s release, the Barnetts, a wealthy picture-per ... Show More
1h 17m
Sep 2023
Missing & Murdered Introduces: Someone Knows Something | Season 8
ost David Ridgen joins victims' family members as they investigate cold cases, tracking down leads, speaking to suspects and searching for answers. In the highly-anticipated 8th season of Someone Knows Something, award-winning investigator David Ridgen delves into a cold case tha ... Show More
48m 13s
May 2021
Baby Hope
Baby Hope was the name given to a four-year-old little girl found dead in a cooler near the Henry Hudson Parkway. Baby Hope's body was found by construction workers in Manhattan, New York, in 1991. Authorities found witnesses but were unable to figure out who Baby Hope was or wha ... Show More
55 m
Sep 2023
Uncover Introduces: Someone Knows Something | Season 8
Host David Ridgen joins victims' family members as they investigate cold cases, tracking down leads, speaking to suspects and searching for answers. In the highly-anticipated 8th season of Someone Knows Something, award-winning investigator David Ridgen delves into a cold case th ... Show More
48m 13s
Jan 2021
S1 Ep6: The Murder of JonBenét Ramsey (Part I)
It was December 26th, 1996 in Boulder Colorado. Boulder had seen a great deal of snow fall the previous week, but by the morning of the 26th, only a trace of it remained, just a small dusting that would most likely disappear as the sun rose. In an upper class Boulder neighborhood ... Show More
1h 44m
Jan 2021
S1 Ep9: The Murder of JonBenét Ramsey (Part IV)
It was December 26th, 1996 in Boulder Colorado. Boulder had seen a great deal of snow fall the previous week, but by the morning of the 26th, only a trace of it remained, just a small dusting that would most likely disappear as the sun rose. In an upper class Boulder neighborhood ... Show More
1h 35m
Jan 2021
S1 Ep7: The Murder of JonBenét Ramsey (Part II)
It was December 26th, 1996 in Boulder Colorado. Boulder had seen a great deal of snow fall the previous week, but by the morning of the 26th, only a trace of it remained, just a small dusting that would most likely disappear as the sun rose. In an upper class Boulder neighborhood ... Show More
1h 40m
Mar 2024
FROM THE VAULT - Episode 305 - Natalia Grace: The Orphan
UPDATE: Since we released our episode on the Barnetts – who said their adopted 9-year-old daughter had turned out to be a murderous, adult woman – Natalia has finally broken her silence in a six(!)-part new interview series.And the revelations are damning…Relisten to the episode ... Show More
1h 49m
Mar 2024
Last Seen presents: "Beyond All Repair," a new murder mystery podcast
Introducing Beyond All Repair, a new WBUR podcast hosted by Amory Sivertson. This series tells the story of a murder, but also the woman who was accused of that murder, Sophia. Sophia was newly married and six months pregnant when she was charged with murdering her mother-in-law ... Show More
25m 33s