logo
episode-header-image
Jun 2021
1h 12m

#74: The Party Monster Murder (Case of M...

STEPHANIE SOO
About this episode

The hottest clubs in New York City were run by Michael. He knew how to throw a party - serving cat food as appetizers, performances of women pulling Christmas lights out of - well, you know where. 


A rotating wheel of 6 cow tongues for anyone to “rub” up against. This was the place to be. 


But when rumors started circling that Michael had injected one of his friends with Drano and dismembered him in his bathtub… nobody believed it. Or maybe they didn’t want to? Because the party must go on. 



Source: "Party Monster" by James St. James - wow... this book is a first-hand account of the whole scene, the environment, but also the crime. Really fantastic read that goes far more in-depth! 
Full Source Notes Here: rottenmangopodcast.com


Up next
Oct 9
“My Parents Were Pedophiles & Forced Me Into Being With Other Pedophiles”- A Day With Lisa Plumb
Family nudist camps. They’re real and exist today. Children are 100% allowed. Clothes are not. A lot of people wonder if it’s uncomfortable for children, which one camp addresses in their website’s FAQs: Q: Are children forced to be nude? A: The word “forced” is an emotionally lo ... Show More
1h 48m
Oct 5
I Saw Luigi Mangione In Court & This Is EVERYTHING That Happened
We went to see Luigi Mangione in court. September 16, 2025, in a New York State Courthouse, Mangione’s terrorism charges are dropped. The courtroom remains silent with court officers stationed at every corner. There are cheers from protestors right outside the courthouse. A stran ... Show More
1h 25m
Sep 28
D4vd Uses Celeste’s Voice In New Songs Months Before Her Body Is Found? + New Updates From Police
It is not until Spetmber 17th, 2025 that the body found in D4vd’s Tesla is identified as 14 year old Celeste Rivas Hernandez. And she has been missing for over a year. The last time her family saw her in person seems to be in April of 2024 though her family has remained out of th ... Show More
2h 14m
Recommended Episodes
Aug 2022
Episode 359: The Club Kid/Party Monster Murder
Michael Alig, or you may know him better as Party Monster, was crowned king of the Club Kids back in the late 80’s/early 90’s. You may have heard of the club kids, some famous examples today are Bjork, Amanda Lepore, and Ru Paul. They ruled the streets of Manhattan when the stree ... Show More
1h 26m
May 2017
#16 - A House Of Horrors in Lino Lakes, Minnesota
This week, we look at the town of Lino Lakes, Minnesota, where a family did their best to try to help one of their own, with the result of 5 senseless murders, that this town will never forget. Along the way, we find out where wild rice grows, how similar a heron is to a flamingo ... Show More
1h 2m
Jul 2023
#404 - The Laughing Psychopath - Marrero, Louisiana
This week, in Marrero, Louisiana, a night of bar hopping & fun leads to a drunken group of people, driving in a car. It all turns very dark, when violence comes out of nowhere, resulting in one of the party ending up beaten, cut, slashed, and face down in the bayou, while the mur ... Show More
1h 8m
Jan 2024
#457 - The Kinky Killer - Penfield, New York
This week, in Penfield, New York, an odd marriage, seems wholesome, but degrades into affairs, finger pointing & parties with escorts. When the wife has finally had it with her husband's cocaine & hired ladies, she decides to have an affair of her own, resulting in much jealously ... Show More
2h 51m
Mar 2017
#8 - A Trail Of Ashes & Bodies in Otisco, New York
This week, we check out the small, upstate New York town of Otisco, where a woman began her career of arson, and murder that would extend across the area, and the years. She escaped justice for over 20 years, before finally having to face her horrible crimes. Along the way, we tr ... Show More
1 h
Mar 2024
The Chris Chatman Do-Over - 10. Murder
Chris shares big news with his co-hosts, who can’t seem to focus on this episode’s guests: true crime podcasters Donna and Jobeth. Starring Ike Barinholtz, Neil Casey, Lisa Gilroy, Liz Cackowski, and Emily Spivey. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: ... Show More
26m 8s
Apr 2024
#485 - Adopting Murder - Cape St Claire, Maryland
This week, in Cape St Claire, Maryland, a couple tries to build a family, by adopting children, who come from rough beginnings, but when they are brutally killed, in their own home, the suspicion falls on the adopted teenage sons. Was it the one who they kicked out of the house, ... Show More
2h 48m
Apr 2024
EP62: Scissor Sisters (Part 1)
The notorious "Scissor Sisters" case ranks among the most brutal and shocking in Irish history, leaving a dark mark on the true crime genre. Linda and Charlotte Mulhall, despite a troubled existence marred by alcohol and drug addiction and a history of abuse, had never shown sign ... Show More
1h 18m
Mar 2024
#472 - Evil Came To Play - Milledgeville, Georgia
This week, in Milledgeville, Georgia, a truly puzzling mystery unfolds when a woman is murdered, after spending a night partying in a hot tub with her boyfriend, and a friend of theirs. When one of the men blows his brains out, with police present, it falls on the other man, who ... Show More
1h 12m