logo
episode-header-image
Jun 2021
30m 28s

Daily: Is MERITOCRACY a myth?

PODMASTERS
About this episode

When people end up in a job or position they love, was it because they worked hard in school, or did they just get lucky? Why is the idea of progressing on merit under threat? Is there a way we can modernise it for the 21st century? Should we we even try?

Adrian Wooldridge, Political Editor of the Economist and author of its Bagehot column, talks to Ros Taylor about his new book The Aristocracy of Talent: How Meritocracy Made the Modern World, why Britain is becoming less meritocratic… and how we can make meritocracy work in today’s world. 

  • “While America claims to be the ultimate meritocracy, they are fascinated by our own aristocracy”
  • “You need competent people to do the work of the world, and aristocrats are quite often born stupid and lazy”
  • “The Davos class of people at the top are divorced from the rest of society, floating above our meritocratic mechanisms”

Presented by Ros Taylor. Produced by Andrew Harrison. Assistant producers Jelena Sofronijevic and Jacob Archbold. Music by Kenny Dickinson. Audio production by Alex Rees. THE BUNKER is a Podmasters Production


See acast.com/privacy for privacy and opt-out information.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Up next
Today
Why is America obsessed with going to war?
The US has a world-class diplomatic corps, yet increasingly its foreign policy is based around war. And while most nations still favour negotiation, Washington seems hooked on force. Today in The Bunker, Chris Jones is joined by Professor David Reynolds, author of Mirrors of Grea ... Show More
34m 21s
Yesterday
No Kids On The Block – What collapsing birthrates really mean
What would the world look like if children became scarcer? Birthrates are falling across the world but the main voices trying to turn them around seem to be weird traditionalist “pronatalists”. Is there a way to encourage having more kids while preserving women’s freedom – and wi ... Show More
39m 56s
Jul 8
Is Big Tech starting to lose?
Is Big Tech really as unstoppable as it looks? In recent months US courts and EU regulators have handed out major reverses to tech giants including Apple, Google, Amazon and Meta. Meanwhile Google search is becoming unusable, choked by ads and its own algorithm, and the growth of ... Show More
38m 55s
Recommended Episodes
Jul 2021
The Promise Of Meritocracy With Adrian Wooldridge
Does meritocracy create a better world for everyone, or does it create massive inequality? There's been a lot of debate in the last few years about meritocracy, and it's become even more pressing in light of the pandemic. If essential workers are "essential", are they really less ... Show More
44m 5s
Sep 2021
Debate: Michael Sandel vs Adrian Wooldridge on Meritocracy
Meritocracy has long been an article of faith in the modern Western world. Get an education, work hard and the rewards of success will be yours, regardless of class, privilege or wealth. But recently meritocracy has come under attack, with the charge led by Michael Sandel, the Ha ... Show More
1h 4m
Sep 2020
158. THE WINNER TAKES IT ALL: the dark side of meritocracy
Hello! We often hear about the idea of meritocracy. But philosopher Michael Sandel thinks it isn’t such a good thing. His new book ’The Tyranny of Merit’ argues the rhetoric of meritocracy is fuelling polarisation and the rise of far right populism. We have a really thought-provo ... Show More
56m 20s
Dec 2020
The Tyranny of Meritocracy | Michael Sandel
Looking for a link we mentioned? It's here: https://linktr.ee/philosophyforourtimesOn Today’s episode we’re discussing meritocracy and social models of success. Is sorting people by merit dangerous and should we be championing an alternative model, one more attentive to the role ... Show More
32m 56s
Jun 2022
265. Meritocracy or Else | Dr. Adrian Wooldridge
Dr. Adrian Wooldridge is a political editor at The Economist and author of the new book ‘The Aristocracy of Talent: How Meritocracy Made the Modern World.’ In this episode, Dr. Wooldridge and I discuss how his new book has been received, the history of meritocracy, how IQ testing ... Show More
1h 18m
Feb 2023
Méritocratie : une illusion française ?
On interroge la question du talent et du mérite… avec l’une des grandes questions qui a surgi en plein débat sur la réforme des retraites : en France, en 2023, QUI MÉRITE QUOI ? Qu’on s’appelle Bernard ARNAULT, ou qu’on fasse partie des “premiers de corvée”, quelle est la part du ... Show More
1h 10m
May 2021
Who Is Inherited Wealth?
If you work hard in the United States, there is no limit to the possibility of what you might achieve. That’s the American Dream. But the reality is that America today increasingly resembles aristocratic societies of the past, which were characterized by little social mobility an ... Show More
47m 23s
Aug 2023
Is Britain a poor country?
Are we the sick man of Europe? We’ve got all the symptoms: broken economy, falling living standards, we could go on. Does anyone have the remedy to get us back up and running again? Plus, it’s nearly the bank holiday, so let’s look on the bright side. The panel discusses who in p ... Show More
1h 2m
Sep 2020
Rogue Nation: Britain scuttles its credibility
As Johnson scrapes his Oven-Ready Deal into the bin, we ask why would any other country ever trust Britain’s word ever again? We explore the new Internal Market Bill’s staggering contempt for international law. And the authors of Left Out: The Inside Story of Labour Under Corbyn ... Show More
59m 30s