logo
episode-header-image
Jun 2021
45m 56s

Covid-Union-Labour-Brexit-Climate

DAVID RUNCIMAN AND CATHERINE CARR
About this episode

This week David and Helen take stock of the state of British politics, looking at how the big themes of the last year fit together. They try to join the dots between the pandemic and the fraying of the Union, the weakness of the Labour party and the fraught politics of climate change, along with the lingering impact of Brexit on everything. We are also looking for your questions on these topics too - please let us know what you would like David and Helen to discuss next: https://www.talkingpoliticspodcast.com/contact


Talking Points: 


Incumbents, under the conditions of vaccine politics, have done well. 

  • The next phase will be about the economy, but we aren’t out of the vaccine stage yet.
  • When an inquiry happens, there will be some tough questions about the British state.
  • If the economic recovery goes well, there will be space for critical reflection. But if recovery stalls or is skewed, that will be the main focus.


The Northern Ireland question may pose a real challenge to the politics of the Union.

  • This may be the government’s number one problem right now.
  • The UK government is extremely constrained. 
  • The EU has invested a lot of its credibility in defending the single market.  
  • The perverse consequence of Brexit is that it embroiled the EU into the politics of Northern Ireland.


Is the First Past the Post system propping up a moribund Labour Party?

  • The electoral system works to Labour’s favour when compared to continental centre-left parties.
  • But the thing that Labour has to deal with that is unique is the Union question.
  • Labour has always struggled to win a majority of seats in England.


In 2020, Britain and the EU diverged on the question of China. 

  • Biden wants to bring the EU toward the American position. And the EU has moved a bit already.
  • This might dilute the advantage that Johnson thought he might gain with the Biden admin by being tough on China.


The geopolitics of climate change are bound up in the EU/US position on China.

  • Merkel has been inclined to treat China as more serious about climate change.
  • Johnson wants to put Britain at the head of ‘green finance.’
  • Climate change is not currently an electorally contested issue in Britain. But that might not be true for much longer.


Mentioned in this Episode: 


Further Learning: 


And as ever, recommended reading curated by our friends at the LRB can be found here: lrb.co.uk/talking

Up next
May 2023
New Podcast: These Times
UnHerd political editor Tom McTague and Cambridge professor Helen Thompson team up to investigate the history of today’s politics — and what it means for our future. Each week they will explore the great forces, ideas and events that led us to where we are, whether in Britain, th ... Show More
52s
Apr 2023
New Podcast: Where Are You Going?
Talking Politics producer Catherine Carr returns to her role as mic-wielder in 'Where Are You Going?' a unique storytelling podcast, delivered in bite-size episodes. Called 'utterly compelling and unique' by the Financial Times, 'engrossing' by The Times and 'riveting' by The Spe ... Show More
3m 39s
Apr 2023
New Podcast: Past Present Future
Past Present Future is a new weekly podcast with David Runciman, host of Talking Politics, exploring the history of ideas from politics to philosophy, culture to technology. David talks to historians, novelists, scientists and many others about where the most interesting ideas co ... Show More
2m 18s
Recommended Episodes
Dec 2020
Time running out for Brexit trade deal
With negotiations on a Brexit trade deal between the UK and EU stalled again, and UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson warning of a no-deal outcome, can the process be salvaged? Plus, with the Brexit arrangements for Northern Ireland resolved this week in a new protocol, has the threa ... Show More
27m 42s
Dec 2018
The Economist asks: Brexit — what next?
Anne McElvoy, our senior editor, takes the temperature in a dramatic week in British politics with John Peet, The Economist’s Brexit editor, and Labour MP Stephen Kinnock, a proponent of a different way to solve the Brexit dilemma. They discuss Theresa May’s next moves, a Norway ... Show More
22m 6s
Nov 2022
Brexit's Back, Alright
Brexit is climbing its way back up the political charts again. Rishi Sunak says his government won't align with European Union rules, while Keir Starmer has told the CBI conference the UK needs to reduce trade barriers with the EU. Our political reporter Ellen Milligan brings us ... Show More
28m 20s
Jan 2021
Britain after Brexit: What’s its role in the world?
The Brexit transition period has ended and a new trade agreement between the United Kingdom and the European Union is in effect. British PM Boris Johnson hailed “the dawn of a new era” saying it marked “a moment of real national renewal and change.” But there’s no consensus on wh ... Show More
49m 57s
Jan 2019
The end of no-deal Brexit and Labour's shifting stance
MPs are likely to demand an end to a no-deal Brexit next week, what does this mean for Theresa May's deal and the Brexit debate? The consequences in Westminster will be huge. Plus is the Labour party shifting towards a second referendum? Or is a general election more likely? Pres ... Show More
35m 24s
Jul 2022
What impact has Brexit had on the UK’s economy?
In 2016 Britain voted to leave the European Union. There were warnings that pulling away from the largest trade bloc in the world would be damaging to the UK’s finances. Those that campaigned for Brexit argued it would offer the UK self-determination and the freedom to forge its ... Show More
24m 7s
Apr 2024
Tory ‘red wall’ seats under threat
Many ‘red wall’ constituencies across northern England, the Midlands and north Wales switched from Labour to the Conservatives in the 2019 general election partly thanks to then prime minister Boris Johnson’s energetic pledge to revitalise struggling communities outside the south ... Show More
33m 59s
Jan 2017
What Would ‘No Deal’ Mean For Brexit Britain?
"No deal is better than a bad deal." So said Britain's Prime Minister Theresa May, clarifying her country's position on Brexit negotiations with the EU. In the absence of a deal with the EU Britain would “revert to WTO rules” after Brexit. But what does that mean, exactly? The In ... Show More
23m 10s
Jan 2022
Histoire d'un Brexit sans fin
Un an après l’entrée en vigueur du nouvel accord commercial entre l’Europe et le Royaume-Uni, quel bilan tirer du Brexit ? De la pêche au statut de l’Irlande du Nord, en passant par le sort des migrants, les points de frictions entre l’Ile et le continent restent nombreux. Nous v ... Show More
48m 30s
May 2024
The issue the political parties won't talk about
After several delays, Brexit checks finally came into force this week - adding cost and delay to how small businesses can get their goods into the UK. It'll see prices pushed up on the consumer's end too.But, you won't hear either main party discussing this in great detail. Why? ... Show More
40m 29s