logo
episode-header-image
Jun 2021
52m 37s

53: The Disappearance of Jamie Fraley

I Think Not!
About this episode
JUST WHEN YOU THINK THIS ONE IS OVER....S**T GOES BANANAS. Jamie Fraley vanished from her North Carolina apartment with no signs of foul play. Then detectives learn that her boyfriend's father had developed an obsession with Jamie while his son was in prison. AND THEN....AND THEN....(in my best Christopher voice) "a grim discovery changes the course of the investigation."

WE'RE DOING OUR FIRST-EVER IN-PERSON LIVE SHOWS! AND WE'RE MAKING A WHOLE WEEKEND OUT OF IT! Friday July 16th And Saturday, July 17th at the iconic Bell House in Brooklyn! There are still some tickets left to the Saturday show. THESE SHOWS ARE GOING TO BE INSANE! WE'VE BEEN LOOKING FORWARD TO DOING LIVE SHOWS FOR A YEAR! We're planning meetups and hang outs for all who come SO CLICK HERE TO GET YOUR TICKETS!

LOOKING FOR MORE PATRICK AND ELLYN? JOIN OUR PATREON! At the $5 level you get 3 FULL BONUS EPISODES PER MONTH! Right now there are over 15 full bonus episode to download and binge right this second! AND YOU GET TO PLAY OUR MONTHLY TRUE CRIME TRIVIA! We do it on Zoom, we all get to hang  out, and you can win cool prizes!!! Plus there are ad-free versions of our entire catalog of episodes! CLICK HERE TO JOIN!
Up next
Aug 20
280: Houston, We Have a Marital Problem (Who the Bleep Did I Marry)
Kaydee Wilson married an aspiring astronaut and was happy until one day her husband committed one of the most outrageous crimes in NASA history. This Week’s Sponsors: Function Health - Learn more and use our link at functionhealth.com/ITHINKNOT BetterHelp - This episode is sponso ... Show More
49m 43s
Aug 19
279: True Crime Rundown: Veronika Rodriguez
On today’s episode of The Rundown, Ellyn and Joey discuss Veronika Rodriguez, a 26-year-old Air National Guard member who reported a sexual assault and was then the one arrested. To hear more in-depth coverage on Veronika’s case, listen to The In Between Podcast with Mel Barrett ... Show More
27m 13s
Aug 13
278: Hearts Afire (Who the Bleep Did I Marry)
Audrey Mabrey fell in love and married a police detective, but after six years all of that would change. This Week’s Sponsors: Remi - Head to shopremi.com/THINK and use code THINK to save up to 50% off Quince - Go to Quince.com/think for free shipping on your order and 365-day re ... Show More
1 h
Recommended Episodes
May 2023
295: The Hillside Strangler(s)
In just over a year, 10 women and girls were found murdered on the hillsides of Los Angles County. There were precious few clues, and, terrifyingly, no pattern. Anyone could be a target. No one was safe. Who was this killer--or killers? And could he ever be stopped? FAM!! WE'RE G ... Show More
57m 41s
Jul 2022
247: Truth And Lies: Monica & Bill
He was the most powerful man in the world. She was 22 year old intern who caught his eye. It was the scandal threatened to ruin them both and to drag the country down with them. AND. OH. MY. GOD. LINDA TRIPP. GOT. IT. ALL. ON. TAPE. PATRICK IS HITTING THE ROAD WITH  MAGGIE, AND L ... Show More
1 h
Mar 2022
232: The Abduction and Murder of Kristin Smart (From Dateline)
On May 25, 1996, 19-year-old college student Kristin Smart went to an off-campus party. Around 2 am, she was last seen being helped back to her dorm by another student named Paul Flores. No one ever saw Kristin again. It would take over 25 years to unravel the mystery of what hap ... Show More
56m 44s
May 2023
296: I Love You, You Hate Me
In 1988, a suburban mom named Sheryl Leach created Barney the Dinosaur as a simple, loving character that she thought her son would love. Within a few years Barney was everywhere. The character and TV show was a billion dollar business and cultural phenomenon.  But fame and fortu ... Show More
1h 2m
Apr 2022
235: Murdered and Missing in Montana
Three young women vanish months apart from each other. Massive searches ensue for each. Days or weeks later, each one is found dead in the location they were last seen. In each case, their deaths are ruled hypothermia even though there's evidence of foul play. How could they have ... Show More
56m 59s
Apr 2022
233: The Murdaugh Murders
On the evening of June 7, 2021, Alex Murdaugh, a member of one of the most powerful families in South Carolina, came home to a brutal scene: The bodies of his 21 year old son, Paul, and 52 year old wife, Maggie. Both of whom had been shot multiple times. Could this be connected t ... Show More
48m 1s
Jul 2021
188: The Housewife and the Hustler
THIS. ONE. IS. WILD. YOU. GUYS. Let us say right up front, Patrick and Gillian have never watched an episode of The Housewives, SO THIS WAS A REAL EDUCATION….And now Patrick identifies as Housewives Curious. OK,  so Beverly Hills Housewife Erik Jane (you guys, I could watch that ... Show More
58m 42s
Jun 2023
299: The Final Days of Whitney Houston
At 3:30 pm On February 11, 2012, 46 year old Whitney Houston--the singing legend and icon--was found unconscious and unresponsive in the bathtub of her room at the Beverly Hills Hotel. She was pronounced dead within the hour. According to police, "there were no obvious sings of c ... Show More
58m 25s
Apr 2022
234: The Murder of Gabby Petito: Truth, Lies, and Social Media
On July 2, 2021, 22-year-old Gabby Petito and her fiance, 23-year-old Briann Laundrie took off on the adventure of a lifetime. Driving cross country on a "vanlife" adventure that Gabby shared with the world via her instagram account. By late August, Gabby stopped communicating wi ... Show More
1h 7m
Dec 2023
The Kit
In the early 1970s, Marty Goddard was worried about the high rates of sexual assault in Chicago. She learned from police that evidence from sexual assault cases often wasn’t collected properly — or at all. “They said, ‘We don’t get evidence.’ And this really kicked everything off ... Show More
50m 14s